|
Nonspecific blood tests, modified Knott’s Test and heartworm antibody detection have been largely replaced by the adult
heartworm antigen assay. A direct relationship exists between the heartworm antigen titer (OD reading) and the degree of
worm burden.
Studies performed by Drs. Courtney and Zeng at the University of Florida and published in CANINE PRACTICE, Vol. 20, pages
15-17, September/October 1995, gave the following data for the two leading manufacturers of heartworm testing kitsSynbiotics
and IDEXX:
| DIROCHEK (SYNBIOTICS) |
| |
Positive |
Negative |
| Heartworms Absent |
0 (0)* |
109 (100) |
| Heartworms Present |
89 (77) |
26 (23) |
| Patent Infections |
50 (98) |
1 (2) |
| Occult Infections |
39 (61) |
25 (39) |
| Gravid Infections |
75 (97) |
2 (3) |
| Female Worms Present |
89 (94) |
6 (6) |
| Female Worms Absent |
0 (0) |
20 (100) |
| Adult Worms Present |
89 (87) |
13 (13) |
| PETCHEK-FF (IDEXX) |
| |
Positive |
Negative |
| Heartworms Absent |
0 (0)* |
109 (100) |
| Heartworms Present |
87 (76) |
28 (24) |
| Patent Infections |
50 (98) |
1 (2) |
| Occult Infections |
37 (58) |
27 (42) |
| Gravid Infections |
75 (97) |
2 (3) |
| Female Worms Present |
87 (92) |
8 (8) |
| Female Worms Absent |
0 (0) |
20 (100) |
| Adult Worms Present |
89 (87) |
15 (15) |
Number of dogs in ench category with percentages in parentheses.
DIROCHEK is a trademark of Synbiotics Corporation. PETCHEK-FF is a trademark of IDEXX Corporation.
From this study, it is clear that the specificity of both assays is 100% (all negatives tested negative), but the
sensitivity for each was approximately equal at around 75%. Therefore, one out of four infected animals tested negative.
The reason for less than satisfactory sensitivity is probably related to cases with relatively low infective worm burden. Accuracy
(which depends on both sensitivity and specificity) is the most important single criterion when selecting a diagnostic test, especially
when the prevalence of heartworm infection is unknown (i.e., nonendemic areas).
Where does this leave the practicing veterinarian? A positive result is diagnostic, but a negative result may be a true negative
or a false negative. A negative obtained during a routine screen on a healthy animal does not warrant a follow up until next season,
but if a negative result is obtained on a symptomatic dog additional confirmatory testing is indicated. This includes: Knott’s test,
microfilarial testing of young adults not receiving macrolide preventives, chest radiographs, and ultrasound or echocardiography.
Microfilarial tests are not reliable for screening dogs receiving heartworm macrolides (ivermectin and milbemycin oxime), because
they are likely to be negative after 6-9 months on these preventives.
Important variables affecting the interpretation of tests results include: likelihood of heartworm disease in the locale and patient,
accuracy of the test used, and prognosis with or without treatment.
|